Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation

AI Decision-Making – Why Strategic Decisions Must Be Calculated Today

Executive Summary: The quality of a decision depends on the alternatives considered

How can companies, executive boards, and public administrations ensure that they actually select the best combination of measures—economically or socially—from among numerous possible options?

Strategic decision-making has traditionally been based on experience, expertise, intuition, business cases, Excel models, and discussions in management committees.

These tools remain indispensable. However, they reach practical limits as soon as numerous investments, projects, and measures compete simultaneously for limited resources.

The challenge does not necessarily lie in a lack of information or decision-making competence.

It lies in the mathematical complexity of the decision space.

In a simplified binary model, a company with 50 planned investment projects faces more than a quadrillion possible project combinations.

No executive board, no investment committee, and no municipal decision-making body can fully examine these alternatives through discussions or manual comparisons.

The crucial question is therefore no longer exclusively:

“Which projects are particularly important or economically attractive?”

But rather:

“Which combination of all available projects achieves the best possible overall result given our budget, resource, and strategic constraints?”

This is precisely where AI-powered mathematical decision optimization comes into play.

StratePlan combines methods from operations research with AI-driven approaches to systematically analyze complex project portfolios and calculate economically efficient combinations.

The goal is not to replace human decisions, but to significantly improve their mathematical foundation.

1. The Core Problem of Modern Decision-Making: Individual Decisions Are Portfolio Decisions

In many organizations, strategic decisions are still considered in isolation.

An investment project is evaluated based on its return on investment. A digitalization initiative is assigned a strategic score. A municipal infrastructure project is prioritized based on urgency.

These individual evaluations are important.

However, they do not automatically answer the question of which combination of all measures produces the best overall result.

The reason is simple: projects compete with one another.

They require capital, personnel, time, technical capacity, and organizational attention.

If a measure is implemented, the resources allocated to it are no longer available for other projects.

This creates interdependencies between individual decisions.

The most economically attractive individual projects therefore do not necessarily result in the best overall portfolio from an economic standpoint.

For example, a project with a high individual rate of return may tie up so much capital that several other projects with a higher combined net value contribution can no longer be financed.

Strategic decision-making must therefore take place at the portfolio level.

The key management question is:

Which combination of our available measures generates the highest overall economic or societal contribution within the existing constraints?

2. Why the decision space grows exponentially: The mathematical principle 2^N

The number of possible project combinations does not grow linearly with the number of projects.

In a simplified binary decision-making model, each project can either be implemented or not implemented.

With N independently selectable projects, there are theoretically 2^N possible combinations.

The scale of this becomes apparent even with a relatively small number of projects:

  • 7 projects: 2^7 = 128 combinations
  • 10 projects: 2^10 = 1,024 combinations
  • 20 projects: 2^20 = 1,048,576 combinations
  • 30 projects: 2^30 = 1,073,741,824 combinations
  • 40 projects: 2^40 = 1,099,511,627,776 combinations
  • 50 projects: 2^50 = 1,125,899,906,842,624 combinations
  • 100 projects: 2^100 = approximately 1.27 × 10^30 combinations

With 50 projects , there are thus approximately 1.126 quadrillion theoretically possible project combinations.

Not every combination is permissible due to budget limits, resource constraints, or project dependencies.

Nevertheless, the sheer scale illustrates why traditional decision-making processes can only consider a limited subset of the entire solution space.

The real challenge is not to evaluate 50 projects individually. It is to determine the best possible permissible combination of these 50 projects.

3. Why Experience, Intuition, and Management Committees Alone Are Not Enough

Experience and expertise are essential foundations of good corporate governance.

They help assess risks, formulate strategic goals, and critically evaluate economic assumptions.

However, human decision-making ability has a mathematical limit.

A board of directors can analyze individual investment projects, discuss their pros and cons, and compare multiple scenarios.

However, it cannot fully examine millions or billions of different project combinations.

In practice, therefore, simplifications are often made:

  • Projects are sorted by individual key metrics.
  • Only the supposedly most important measures are examined in depth.
  • Alternative project combinations are put together manually.
  • Investment budgets are allocated to business units.
  • Strategic priorities are determined through weighting or committee decisions.

These approaches may be organizationally sound and necessary.

However, they do not guarantee that the selected combination of projects will achieve the maximum possible overall contribution.

The limitations of human decision-making in complex portfolios lie not primarily in a lack of knowledge, but in the limited ability to compare an exponentially large number of alternatives with one another.

Mathematical optimization therefore complements human decision-making with a systematic exploration of the solution space.

4. A Simple Example: Why the Best Individual Decision Is Not the Best Overall Decision

A company has an investment budget of 10 million euros.

There are three projects to choose from.

Project Investment Net Value Contribution
Project A €7 million €4 million
Project B €5 million €3 million
Project C 5 million € €3 million

Project A has the highest single net value contribution.

If Project A is selected, 3 million euros of the budget will remain. This is not enough for any of the other projects.

The total net value contribution is therefore 4 million euros.

However, a mathematical analysis of the possible combinations reveals a more economically viable alternative.

Projects B and C together require 10 million euros and generate a combined net value contribution of 6 million euros.

Assuming the projects are independent and there are no other restrictions, B + C is the optimal combination for maximizing the net value contribution.

The mathematically optimized project combination thus generates a net value contribution that is 50% higher than that of the original selection.

The company does not need any additional investment capital for this.

It simply needs to select a different combination of its existing projects.

This example shows that an economically sound individual decision can still be suboptimal at the portfolio level.

5. Decision-Making with AI: From Prioritization to Mathematical Optimization

AI-supported decision-making can perform a variety of tasks.

Generative AI, for example, assists with analyzing information, formulating decision-making templates, or summarizing complex issues.

Forecasting models can estimate future developments.

Mathematical decision optimization, on the other hand, pursues a different goal.

It examines which combination of available courses of action, within defined constraints, best fulfills a specific objective function.

To do this, the decision-making problem is described as a mathematical model.

Typical components include:

  • Decision variables: Which projects will be implemented?
  • Objective function: Which overall economic or social contribution should be maximized?
  • Budget constraints: How much capital is available?
  • Resource constraints: What personnel and technical capacities are available?
  • Project dependencies: Which measures must be implemented together or in a specific order?
  • Strategic Guidelines: Which projects or impact goals must be taken into account?

These specifications give rise to a combinatorial optimization problem.

Appropriate algorithms search or analyze the mathematical solution space and identify efficient, feasible project combinations.

Depending on the problem structure and the method used, a solution that is either provably global or approximately optimal can be found.

A complete individual calculation of all 2^N combinations is not strictly necessary for this.

The key advancement lies in mathematically analyzing complex portfolio decisions rather than merely comparing a few manually selected scenarios with one another.

6. How StratePlan Mathematically Optimizes Strategic Decisions

StratePlan was developed to analyze complex investment and project portfolios using mathematical optimization methods.

The technology combines approaches from operations research with AI-supported methods to efficiently search for high-performing project combinations.

For a basic economic optimization model, only three pieces of information per project are initially required:

  1. Project ID: Unique identifier for the project
  2. Expenses: Planned expenditures or investments
  3. Income: Expected revenue or economic returns

In addition, the available investment budget is defined.

The data can be imported, for example, from existing Excel investment plans.

StratePlan analyzes possible project combinations and calculates a portfolio composition based on the selected objective function.

With “Maximize Net Contribution,” the focus is on maximizing the total expected net value contribution.

The portfolio ROI can also be reported as an economic metric.

Advanced models can account for additional constraints and valuation parameters:

  • Project dependencies
  • Strategic weightings
  • Resource and capacity constraints
  • Multi-year investment budgets
  • Time constraints
  • Risk and sustainability criteria

The result is not merely a ranking of individual projects, but a mathematically calculated combination of projects within the defined parameters.

StratePlan thus supplements strategic decision-making with a level of mathematical optimization.

7. Live in the Board Meeting: Calculate Strategic Scenarios on the Spot

Mathematical decision optimization becomes particularly valuable when it is used directly in management and executive board meetings.

Let’s imagine an industrial conglomerate with 100 planned investment projects.

The total of all proposed investments exceeds the available CAPEX budget.

Management must decide which projects to implement.

StratePlan first calculates an optimized combination of projects based on existing economic assumptions.

Different scenarios can then be examined during the board meeting.

Scenario A: Maximum total economic contribution

The CFO asks:

“Which combination of our planned investments yields the highest expected net value contribution within the existing CAPEX budget?”

StratePlan calculates a corresponding project portfolio.

Management receives an overview of the selected projects, the required capital investment, and the expected total economic contribution.

Scenario B: Reduced Investment Budget

The CEO asks:

“What happens if we have to reduce our investment budget by 15%?”

The budget constraint is adjusted.

StratePlan recalculates the portfolio.

Management can see which projects will be eliminated and how the expected net value contribution changes.

Scenario C: Mandatorily Include Strategic Projects

Another member of the executive board asks:

“How does our optimal project mix change if certain strategic investments must be implemented?”

The relevant projects are taken into account as binding constraints.

The portfolio is optimized again.

The comparison shows the economic impact of the additional strategic requirement within the model.

Scenario D: Additional Investment Capital

The CFO wants to know:

“What additional economic contribution could we achieve if we increased our CAPEX budget by another 20 million euros?”

The budget is adjusted, and a new calculation is performed.

Management can compare the modeled additional value contribution with the required capital investment.

Scenario E: Changed Strategic Priorities

The Executive Board asks:

“How will our portfolio change if we place greater emphasis on digitalization, energy efficiency, or specific growth areas?”

The corresponding parameters are adjusted.

StratePlan calculates a new combination of projects and allows for comparison with the previous scenarios.

Change the budget. Adjust strategic guidelines. Recalculate the portfolio. Compare economic impacts.

This transforms static investment planning into a dynamic foundation for strategic decisions.

8. Ex-ante Decision-Making: Determining the Best Combination Before Implementation

Traditional corporate management often focuses on the retrospective evaluation of decisions that have already been made.

Controlling analyzes revenue, EBIT, ROI, return on investment, and budget variances.

These metrics show what financial results were achieved.

However, they do not automatically answer the question of whether a different combination of projects would have been more successful.

Mathematical ex-ante optimization therefore begins even before capital is committed.

It examines which combination of planned measures, within the available resources, achieves the highest expected total contribution.

This shift in perspective is fundamental.

Ex post: “How successful was our decision?”

Ex ante: “Which decision promises the best overall result based on our assumptions?”

Through mathematical portfolio optimization, companies can compare alternative project combinations even before they are implemented.

This can help reduce economic misallocations and reveal untapped value-creation potential.

The quality of strategic decisions is thus not evaluated only after they are implemented, but is systematically examined during the decision-making process itself.

9. Opportunity Costs: What is the cost of a suboptimal decision?

Every investment decision ties up capital and resources.

This capital is then no longer available for other projects.

This results in opportunity costs.

They describe the lost benefits of the best alternative that was not chosen.

A company may select economically attractive projects and still fail to realize a significant additional value contribution.

Mathematical portfolio optimization makes it possible to compare the originally planned investment portfolio with an optimized combination of projects.

Among other things, the following key metrics can be compared:

  • Total investment requirement
  • Expected net value contribution
  • Portfolio ROI
  • Selected and non-selected projects
  • Remaining budget flexibility
  • Economic differences between alternative portfolios

The difference between the modeled results shows the potential for economic improvement under the underlying assumptions.

If the global optimum has been mathematically proven, the distance between a selected project combination and this optimum can be precisely determined within the model.

For approximately optimal solutions, the difference from the best solution found is first reported.

The key added value lies in identifying potential economic drawbacks of a portfolio decision even before it is implemented.

10. Sensitivity Analysis: How Robust Is a Mathematically Optimized Decision?

Strategic decisions are based on assumptions about future developments.

Investment costs may rise. Expected revenues may turn out to be lower. Resources may become scarcer. Strategic priorities may change.

Therefore, mathematical optimization should not consider only a single scenario.

By making targeted changes to the input parameters, different economic developments can be simulated.

Typical questions include:

  • Which projects will remain part of the portfolio even with a reduced budget?
  • Which investments are particularly sensitive to rising costs?
  • How does the net value contribution change when revenue expectations are lower?
  • What combination of projects emerges when strategic weightings are adjusted?
  • Which measures remain economically attractive under various scenarios?

These sensitivity analyses can show how stable a calculated project mix remains under changing conditions.

A sound strategic decision therefore takes into account not only the best outcome under a single assumption but also the effects of potential changes.

11. Case Study: Klybeck Site in Basel – Approximately 63% Higher Return on Investment

The StratePlan case study of the Klybeck site in Basel illustrates the economic potential that mathematical portfolio optimization can unlock.

As part of the portfolio optimization for Central Real Estate AG and Swiss Life AG, existing investment and project alternatives were analyzed mathematically.

The modeled result:

  • Original return on investment: 7.0%
  • Optimized return on investment: 11.4%
  • Relative return improvement: approximately 63%
  • Additional modeled economic value contribution: approximately 30 million CHF

The improvement was modeled by changing the combination of existing investment alternatives while maintaining the same budget.

These project-specific results do not constitute a general guarantee of return.

The key insight: A higher overall economic contribution can be achieved simply by better combining existing investment alternatives—without an additional investment budget.

12. Decision-Making with AI in Businesses and Public Administrations

Mathematical decision optimization is relevant wherever numerous measures compete for limited financial or operational resources.

Industry and Strategic CAPEX Planning

Machinery investments, production capacities, automation projects, and facility expansions must be selected within shared investment budgets.

Mathematical portfolio optimization can help identify economically more efficient combinations of these measures.

Digitalization and AI Transformation

Companies often have numerous potential AI and digitalization projects.

The key challenge is to select those initiatives that, taken together, will yield the greatest economic return within the available resources.

Real Estate

Project developments, renovations, modernizations, and location investments can be optimized within a shared capital budget.

The selection of individual projects influences the financing options for the entire portfolio.

Energy and Infrastructure

Energy projects, grid investments, efficiency measures, and infrastructure upgrades often require long-term capital commitments.

Mathematical optimization can help compare different investment combinations under economic and technical constraints.

Municipalities and Public Budgets

Cities and municipalities must finance numerous investment projects within limited budgetary constraints.

Schools, roads, administrative buildings, infrastructure, and social services all compete for the same public resources.

The challenge lies in reconciling financial constraints with political priorities, legal obligations, and social impact goals.

Mathematical portfolio optimization can calculate different combinations of measures and illustrate the effects of changes in budget and weighting specifications.

The overarching question is: Which combination of available measures achieves the highest overall economic or social benefit under the defined conditions?

13. Budget Simulation and Simultaneous Optimization of Municipal Investment Programs

Of particular interest is the integration of mathematical portfolio optimization with the simulation of public budgets.

Municipal decision-makers regularly face the challenge of financing numerous investment requests with limited budgetary resources.

An example:

A city has an investment budget of 81 million euros.

At the same time, there are 50 planned projects with a total investment requirement of 220 million euros to choose from.

The central question is not solely which projects appear to be particularly important from a political or technical standpoint.

Which combination of these 50 projects achieves the highest defined overall economic or social benefit within the available budget?

With 50 binary project decisions, there are theoretically 2^50 = 1,125,899,906,842,624 possible combinations.

Mathematical portfolio optimization can examine various permissible project combinations within the defined budget and impact constraints.

A simultaneous budget simulation allows for changes in financial conditions to be taken into account.

For example:

  • How does the optimal project selection change with a reduced investment budget?
  • Which additional projects could be financed if revenues were higher?
  • What economic or social impacts result from mandatory policy projects?
  • How does the portfolio change if greater emphasis is placed on education, infrastructure, or climate protection?
  • Which combination of projects yields the highest modeled total benefit within the available budget?

The results depend on the quality of the input data and the definition of the economic and societal targets.

Combining budget simulation with mathematical portfolio optimization can help policymakers transparently compare alternative policy packages and systematically analyze the impact of limited budget resources.

14. From Business Intelligence to Decision Intelligence

Business Intelligence primarily examines an organization’s economic performance.

What happened? Which KPIs have changed? Where are there deviations from the plan?

Decision Intelligence expands this perspective to include systematic support for future decisions.

What alternatives are available? What constraints apply? Which combination of projects best meets the defined objectives?

StratePlan supplements existing ERP, controlling, and business intelligence systems with a mathematical optimization layer.

The required project data can initially be provided via simple Excel spreadsheets.

This enables companies and public institutions to use existing investment plans as a starting point for systematic portfolio optimization.

The key difference lies in not only measuring the economic consequences of decisions already made, but also mathematically analyzing alternative decisions before they are implemented.

15. Conclusion: Strategic decisions require a mathematical foundation

Strategic decision-making becomes increasingly complex as the number of projects and constraints grows.

Experience, expertise, and management skills remain indispensable.

However, they alone are not sufficient to systematically analyze exponentially large decision spaces.

Even with just 50 projects, there are more than a quadrillion theoretically possible combinations.

Therefore, evaluating individual projects in isolation does not automatically answer the question of what constitutes the best possible overall portfolio.

Mathematical decision optimization makes it possible to analyze complex investment and initiative portfolios while taking economic goals, available budgets, and defined constraints into account.

To this end, StratePlan combines methods from operations research with AI-based approaches.

This enables companies, executive boards, and public decision-makers to calculate alternative project combinations, compare different scenarios, and identify untapped economic or societal potential.

The crucial question is no longer: Which projects do we consider the best?

But rather: Which combination of our available projects achieves the best possible overall result under the given conditions?

This is precisely where the transition from traditional project prioritization to mathematical decision optimization begins.

StratePlan – Same projects. Same budget. Optimal combination. Better results.

FAQ – Decision-Making with AI

What exactly does decision-making with AI mean?

Decision-making with AI describes the use of algorithmic systems to support complex decisions.

In the field of mathematical portfolio optimization, available courses of action, economic objectives, and constraints are analyzed within a single model.

The goal is to identify the most effective feasible combination of actions.

How does AI-supported decision-making differ from traditional analyses?

Traditional decision-making processes often compare individual projects or a few predefined scenarios.

Mathematical portfolio optimization, on the other hand, examines the combination of various measures under shared budget and resource constraints.

This can reveal economically more attractive alternatives that would be overlooked if only individual projects were considered.

What does 2^N mean in the context of strategic decisions?

2^N describes the number of theoretically possible combinations for N independent binary decisions.

Each project can either be selected or not selected.

With 20 projects, there are 2^20 = 1,048,576 possible combinations.

With 50 projects, there are 2^50 = 1,125,899,906,842,624 possible combinations.

The combinations that are actually permissible depend on the defined constraints.

Does AI actually have to compute all 2^N combinations individually?

No.

Modern mathematical optimization methods can efficiently explore large decision spaces without having to fully evaluate every theoretically possible combination individually.

Which methods are suitable depends on the mathematical structure of the problem and the defined constraints.

Can AI compute the global optimum of a decision?

With suitable mathematical models and optimization methods, a global optimum can be calculated and proven.

For particularly complex problems, approximately optimal solutions can also be used.

Any statement regarding the quality of the solution must therefore align with the method used and the available proof of optimality.

Does AI replace management’s decision?

No.

Management defines the economic and strategic objectives, sets constraints, and evaluates the results.

AI-supported mathematical optimization provides additional decision-making criteria.

Ultimate responsibility remains with the relevant managers or political decision-makers.

For which decisions is mathematical AI particularly well-suited?

It is particularly relevant for complex portfolio decisions involving numerous competing projects and limited resources.

Typical areas of application include CAPEX planning, digitalization portfolios, AI use cases, industrial investments, real estate projects, energy programs, and municipal budget planning.

What does ex ante decision-making mean?

“Ex ante” means analyzing a decision before it is implemented.

In mathematical portfolio optimization, alternative project combinations are calculated before capital is committed or measures are initiated.

This allows the economic impacts of different decisions to become apparent at an early stage.

How reliable are AI-supported decision outcomes?

The quality of the results depends on the underlying data, the definition of the objective function, the modeling of constraints, and the optimization method used.

Mathematical optimization enables reproducible and transparent calculations.

Sensitivity analyses can also show how results change when assumptions are altered.

Is AI-driven decision-making only useful for large corporations?

No.

Small and medium-sized enterprises, municipalities, and other organizations can also benefit from mathematical portfolio optimization.

What matters is not just the size of the organization, but the complexity of the decision and the number of competing options.

What data does StratePlan need for an initial calculation?

For a basic economic optimization model, three pieces of information are initially required for each project:

  • Project ID
  • Expenses – planned expenditures
  • Income – expected revenue or economic returns

In addition, the available investment budget must be specified.

More complex models can take additional constraints and evaluation parameters into account.

Can StratePlan simulate different budget scenarios?

Yes. Different budget limits can be modeled as alternative scenarios.

This allows you to examine which combination of projects is selected given a lower or higher investment budget and how the expected total economic contribution changes.

What is the difference between project prioritization and portfolio optimization?

Project prioritization ranks individual measures.

Portfolio optimization determines which combination of these measures achieves the best overall result under the defined constraints.

Therefore, the best ranking is not automatically the best project portfolio.

What is the most important takeaway for CEOs, CFOs, and public decision-makers?

Complex strategic decisions should not be based solely on the evaluation of individual projects or a small number of manually selected scenarios.

Mathematical portfolio optimization enables a systematic analysis of alternative project combinations, thereby providing an additional basis for well-informed decisions.

AI does not replace responsibility. However, it can help identify better economic or societal alternatives for action.

Which combination of your projects yields the best result?

Find out which combination of your planned investment projects can achieve the highest expected net value contribution within your available budget.

Get started with your own project data and compare mathematically optimized investment scenarios.

You can optimize up to 15 projects for free.

Optimize up to 15 projects for free now →

Industry / CAPEX

End guesswork for investments in the millions

Calculate business and investment decisions now
Check investment potential

Public Sector

Too many projects, too little budget

Calculate more projects with the same budget
Analyze budget potential
Subscribe to newsletter
Privacy
By selecting continue you confirm that you have read our and accepted our .
Fields marked with asterisks (*) are required.